A recent fan-made “documentary” has gone viral, attempting to portray Hailey Bieber as an obsessive stalker of her now-husband, Justin Bieber, and his ex-girlfriend, Selena Gomez. However, dedicated fans of all three celebrities have pushed back against these claims, citing factual inaccuracies and misleading narratives.
The evidence includes a widely shared video of Hailey watching Justin on the Today Show in 2009. Critics point out that this footage was taken on the same day she first met Justin through her father, Stephen Baldwin, who was hosting the show. The documentary misrepresents the timeline to create a false narrative.
Debunking the lies of the fan-made “documentary” about Hailey Bieber being a stalker of Justin Bieber or Selena Gomez, a thread: 🧵 pic.twitter.com/J7FvQ7F8GE
— bizzle (@bieberitboy) March 22, 2025Hailey Bieber’s Industry Connections
Another claim suggests that Hailey attended multiple Justin Bieber events as a fan. However, as part of the Baldwin family, she was regularly invited to high-profile industry events, including premieres for Demi Lovato, One Direction, Miley Cyrus, and Bruno Mars. Given her family’s entertainment background, her presence at Justin-related events was not unusual.
Additionally, Hailey had her career in the entertainment industry. In 2011, she appeared in Cody Simpson’s music video for “On My Mind,” further debunking claims that she was solely focused on Justin. At the Monte Carlo premiere in 2011, she was specifically asked about working with Simpson, contradicting claims that she attended purely for Selena and Justin.
Hailey Bieber has been rocking a "B" necklace for years and now Selena Gomez is wearing one.
Had this been the other way around, this would have provoked another 7-part Hailey documentary. The double standard is clear. https://t.co/r9px3HJUMy
— A. (@ScandalousMedia) March 20, 2025Some fans have accused Hailey of copying Selena Gomez’s tattoos, particularly the small “G” tattoo behind her ear. However, this tattoo was done in honour of Georgia Veach, a young girl battling a severe illness, and has been inked by multiple celebrities, including Julia Zingaro.
Read: Hailey Bieber Responds to Justin Bieber Instagram Unfollow Rumors
Similarly, accusations that Hailey mimicked Selena’s clothing choices have been challenged with side-by-side comparisons showing distinct fashion styles.
Fact vs. Fiction: Debunking Viral Claims
Several viral claims, such as Hailey supposedly copying Selena’s cooking show concept, have also been debunked. Hailey and Justin shared their first cooking segment in May 2020, months before Selena + Chef premiered in August 2020. Fans have also highlighted instances where Justin himself appeared to pursue Hailey, contradicting the notion of her as an obsessive follower.
Read: Justin Bieber Europe Move Rumored with Hailey
Supporters argue that these misleading narratives are fueled by fan rivalry rather than factual evidence. The ongoing speculation stirs unnecessary drama, but dedicated fans remain committed to setting the record straight with verified timelines and logical counterarguments.
