A federal appeals court determined that Donald Trump lacks immunity against charges linked to efforts to reverse his 2020 election loss, edging him toward a potential criminal trial.
The court, specifically the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, dismissed Trump’s argument for immunity, citing his presidential duties. The unanimous decision emphasized that the presidential office does not grant lifelong legal immunity. Consequently, effective during his presidency, Trump’s executive immunity does not apply to current charges. Trump plans to challenge this decision, asserting it undermines foundational democratic principles. His team suggests that lacking total immunity impedes presidential functionality. Meanwhile, Special Counsel Jack Smith’s office has not commented, awaiting Trump’s appeal to the Supreme Court.
The case is on hold, allowing Trump appeal time. His legal team has argued for broad protections for former presidents, contending that criminal prosecution requires prior impeachment and Senate removal. Despite two House impeachments, Senate Republicans prevented conviction.
The court scrutinized Trump’s broad immunity claim, questioning whether it would protect a president who orders an assassination without Congressional intervention. The ruling argued such immunity would dangerously empower presidents, dismissing the need for full protection for actions undertaken in office.
Trump, campaigning and suggesting potential prosecution against Joe Biden, faces charges from Smith for allegedly using voter fraud claims to disrupt the 2020 election certification. He denies all charges, citing political bias. Judge Tanya Chutkan previously rejected the immunity defence, causing trial delays. Trump’s trial date remains unset, with potential self-pardon or case dismissal if re-elected.
