A single social media post from Hailey Bieber has reignited widespread online debate about her relationship with Justin Bieber, highlighting how closely fans continue to scrutinise the couple’s history.
On New Year’s Eve, the 29-year-old skincare entrepreneur shared a throwback photo on Instagram, marking what she described as ten years of welcoming the new year with Justin. The post appeared simple and nostalgic, yet it quickly drew intense attention across social media platforms.
Online users were quick to point out that Justin and Hailey officially reconnected in 2018, following a brief relationship in 2015, and married just months later. This prompted renewed speculation over which specific New Year celebrations the couple shared, with some fans questioning possible overlaps during periods when Justin was also linked to Selena Gomez.
Hailey Baldwin Bieber is so embarrassing mind u she was all over Justin’s friend on new years yet claiming she was w Justin for 10 yrs & the years he was literally w Selena….wether JELENA were on it off girly desperate to rewrite history/….she think ppl won’t remember… pic.twitter.com/2wpkKX5Gyf
— 🍑 (@SweetartChef) January 2, 2026The discussion gained momentum as users revisited past interviews and clips in which Justin and Hailey described their early relationship as non-exclusive. Those resurfaced moments reopened long-standing debates around the timeline of Justin’s relationships, which many observers have long described as complex and overlapping.
The renewed scrutiny comes after a turbulent year for the couple. During the summer, Justin and Hailey faced persistent rumours of marital strain and possible separation. They countered the speculation through public appearances, interviews, and the release of Justin’s albums Swag and Swag II, both of which offered personal and emotional insights into his life and marriage.
Read:Hailey Bieber Silently Responds to Justin Bieber Rumors with Subtle Instagram Post
Despite the latest wave of online commentary, neither Justin nor Hailey has responded to the renewed speculation. For now, the couple appears to be maintaining their usual silence, even as social media continues to dissect a relationship under constant public scrutiny.
