Skip to content
Photonews Logo Photonews logo
  • Home
  • Pakistan
    • Punjab
    • Sindh
    • Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    • Azad Jammu Kashmir
    • Balochistan
    • Gilgit – Baltistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Videos
    Nero and Rocco in Pixar’s Gatto trailer, voiced by Mark Ruffalo and Laurence Fishburne.
    EntertainmentVideos

    Mark Ruffalo’s Gatto Trailer Reveals Nero’s Venice Adventure

    November 13, 2026 2 Min Read
    Jimmy Kimmel President Trump
    EntertainmentVideos

    Jimmy Kimmel Urges Trump to Resign After US Midterms

    November 6, 2026 2 Min Read
    Canadian actor Eugene Levy and Second City Television (SCTV)
    EntertainmentVideos

    Eugene Levy Reveals SCTV Episodes Cost Just $7,000

    November 5, 2026 2 Min Read
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Offbeat
  • Blog
  • Contact
Reading: Can Civilians Be Tried Like APS Attackers? Justice Hilali Questions
PhotoNews PakistanPhotoNews Pakistan
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • Home
  • Pakistan
    • Punjab
    • Sindh
    • Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    • Balochistan
    • Azad Jammu Kashmir
    • Gilgit – Baltistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Videos
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Offbeat
  • Blog
  • Contact
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Photonews. All Rights Reserved.
Supreme Court 27th Constitutional Amendment Pakistan
PhotoNews Pakistan > Pakistan > Can Civilians Be Tried Like APS Attackers? Justice Hilali Questions
Pakistan

Can Civilians Be Tried Like APS Attackers? Justice Hilali Questions

Web Desk
By Web Desk Published January 8, 2025 3 Min Read
Share
Supreme Court of Pakistan. Photo: Business Recorder
SHARE

Supreme Court Justice Musarrat Hilali raised concerns about the appropriateness of military trials for civilians during a Wednesday hearing during discussions on intra-court appeals against the military trial of civilians under a constitutional bench led by Justice Amin-Ud-Din Khan.

Defense Ministry representative Khawaja Haris resumed his argument, citing a Supreme Court decision invalidating civilian military trials. Haris insisted that previous rulings allow for civilian trials in military courts, although he argued that the Constitution’s recent interpretations of Articles 8(3) and 8(5) were incorrect.

Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail responded to Haris and said the bench would consider his points carefully.

Haris addressed a common misunderstanding about the FB Ali case, explaining that Brigadier FB Ali faced trial as a civilian after his retirement. This detail distinguishes his case, as Ali had not retired at the time of the offence.

Read: Civilians May Face Military Trial for Specific Army Act Offenses, Says SC Judge

Justice Mandokhail highlighted that the accused in the ongoing case, related to the events of May 9, had no military connections. “These individuals weren’t even ex-servicemen; they were merely civilians,” he stated, questioning the scope of the Army Act’s application to civilians.

Ignoring public opinion, Justice Mandokhail urged Haris to clarify whether the Army Act encompasses civilian trials.

Justice Hilali then questioned whether applying the Army Act would suspend all fundamental rights. Concurrently, Justice Mohammad Ali Mazhar asked about international norms for such trials, to which Haris promised to provide international examples later.

Justice Mandokhail also raised the issue of military trials for terrorists who attack and kill Pakistani soldiers, questioning why such cases are not handled in military courts.

Harris emphasized that the current case did not address future trial prospects. He confirmed existing legal precedents during the debate on the eligibility of certain civilian cases for military trials under Article 8, Section 3.

Justice Hilali reaffirmed that the constitution remains in effect and judicial decisions protect fundamental rights.

The Supreme Court had previously ruled on October 23 last year that civilian trials in military courts are unconstitutional. Still, a six-member bench, including Justice Hilali, temporarily halted this decision on December 13, 2023, following challenges to the verdict.

TAGGED:Featured
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Email Copy Link Print
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement

HBL Asset Management
HBL Asset Management

Recent Posts

Russian cargo ship Sparta II engulfed in flames and thick black smoke after a drone attack in the Gulf of Finland.

Russian Ship Sparta II Burns for Second Day Off Finland

Pakistan and Lebanon flags waving side by side on flagpoles.

Zardari Urges Israeli Withdrawal From Lebanon in Letter

President Asif Ali Zardari, Ishaq Dar and National Assembly Speaker Sardar Ayaz Sadiq during a meeting in Pakistan.

Zardari Meets Ishaq Dar, Ayaz Sadiq for Political Talks

Post Archives

More Popular from Photonews

Jeffrey Epstein's 2017 sex offender registry photograph released by the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services.
Top NewsWorld

Jeffrey Epstein Russia Ties Show Recruitment, Putin Bid

3 Min Read
Fatah-3 supersonic cruise missile launched during a Pakistan Army missile test, with smoke and flames rising from the launcher.
Pakistan

Pakistan Army Tests Fatah-3 Supersonic Cruise Missile

2 Min Read
Pakistan telecom subscribers PTA FY2024-25 Annual Report
Pakistan

PTA Inspects 226 Mobile Sites Across 16 Pakistani Areas

1 Min Read
Tech

France Blames Iran for Supermarket Hack, Seeks EU Sanctions

BRUSSELS: France is seeking European Union sanctions over an alleged Iranian cyberattack on supermarket refrigeration systems.…

November 16, 2026
Top NewsWorld

Mexico Arrests ‘El Chapo Isidro’, an FBI Most Wanted Fugitive

GUASAVE, Mexico: Mexican forces arrested alleged cartel leader Fausto Isidro Meza-Flores, known as “El Chapo Isidro”,…

November 21, 2026
Entertainment

Noah Kahan Addresses Grammy Disappointment at London Show

LONDON: Singer-songwriter Noah Kahan addressed his disappointment over the 2027 Grammy nominations during Tuesday’s concert, changing…

November 18, 2026
Entertainment

Ron Howard Says Grinch Sequel Needs Script Before Return

Director Ron Howard says a Grinch sequel is in development at Imagine Entertainment, but he and…

November 18, 2026
PhotoNews Pakistan

Always Stay Up to Date

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

    Categories

    • World
    • Pakistan
    • Punjab
    • Sindh
    • Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    • Balochistan
    • Azad Jammu Kashmir

     

    • Top News
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Videos
    • Tech
    • Offbeat
    • Blog
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Code of Ethics & Editorial Standards

    © 2026 Phototnews
    All Rights Reserved.

    Welcome Back!

    Sign in to your account

    Lost your password?